The first page to answer the three questions, and the second one to write 4 response comments ( the file will be attached by Saturday)

1. please indicate whether there is value in a budget policy if it is ignored.

(NOT NOW) Please provide at least one response comment to the substantive comment of two other group discussion members.

2. Public budgeting is often conflictual.  please identify conflict in the budget process in your community over the past year. The conflict should be covered and appropriately cited in a media report. It should involve one of the sources of conflict in the budget process as mentioned in Figure 8-3 (( attached file)) Please ensure that you identify what type  of conflict is involved based on Figure 8-3.

(NOT NOW) Please provide at least one response comment to the substantive comment of two other group discussion members.

3.  please explain what you got out of the exercise(( attached file)) and what surprised you the most?

(NOT NOW) Please provide at least one response comment to the substantive comment of two other group discussion members.